WASHINGTON (AP) - Mitt Romney's Medicare plan won't try to control costs by limiting the payments that future retirees would use to buy private health insurance, aides say. Budget experts are questioning how the Republican candidate will be able to get savings without caps.
Reining in costs is vital to keeping Medicare affordable, and in their plans both President Barack Obama and Romney's running mate, Paul Ryan, set limits on the growth of future spending. Romney's approach is different.
Romney campaign officials say Medicare savings will come through competition among health insurance plans. But independent experts say they doubt that Romney's plan can succeed without some kind of hard spending-limit.
"It sounds like Romney is trying to have it both ways," said Robert Bixby, executive director of the Concord Coalition, a nonpartisan group advocating to reduce government deficits. "It's a really important point whether there will be a cap. It will help determine whether the health care savings he's touting are credible."
For example, a President Romney would not be able to get credit for assumed savings through competition under the procedures currently used to analyze legislation by the all-important Congressional Budget Office. The nonpartisan budget referees might rule such a plan out of bounds, forcing Romney to accept a cap.
"This is pure Romney-speak," said Rep. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., ranking Democrat on the House Budget Committee. "Everybody knows the way they achieve savings through their voucher plan is to impose a cap. Otherwise it's laughable to claim any savings."
In the world of private business, competition hasn't solved the health care cost problem for employers, who increasingly have been shifting costs to workers and their families in the form of higher premiums and copays. "Competition alone is very speculative," Bixby said.
Bixby was a member of a Bipartisan Policy Center group that last year produced a deficit reduction plan that, like Romney's, called for shifting Medicare from an open-ended benefit to a program that gives future retirees a fixed amount of money for health insurance. It included a cap on the growth of spending.
Medicare covers nearly 50 million retirees and disabled people. Since its creation in 1965, it has been an open-ended benefit program, with taxpayers basically paying all the bills that come in.
Obama's health care law begins to change that, creating a board with the power to force payment cuts on the health care industry if Medicare costs rise above certain limits.
Ryan's budget, passed by the House this year, also would limit the growth of total Medicare spending, using a formula that links to economic growth.
Romney has charged that Obama's approach would eventually lead to rationing.
Obama has "an unelected board ... to decide what kind of treatment you ought to have," Romney said during Wednesday night's presidential debate in Denver. The board is prohibited by law from rationing care.
Romney calls his own plan "premium support." Critics say it would amount to a cost shift.
Aides to the GOP candidate say the plan would rely on competition — without caps or a cost-cutting board — to control spending and avoid cost shifts to seniors.
Retirees entering the program in 2022 and later would have the choice of private insurance or a government plan modeled on traditional Medicare.
The private plans would bid to provide health care to seniors in a given part of the country. The government's payment would be pegged to the second-lowest bid, or the cost of the government plan, whichever was lower.
Seniors who chose a higher-cost plan would pay the difference. Those who picked lower-cost coverage could keep the difference for medical expenses. Low-income retirees and people in poor health would get a more generous government payment.
The Romney campaign refused repeated requests for an on-the-record explanation of the strategy for limiting Medicare costs.
Instead, spokeswoman Andrea Saul issued a statement extolling what she called "a plan that empowers patients and families with more choices and robust competition, reforms insurance markets with strong consumer protections and proposes real entitlement reform that protects and strengthens Medicare for today's seniors and future generations."
In an earlier blog post rebutting Democratic critics of Romney's Medicare proposal, his campaign policy director Lanhee Chen made an indirect reference to the candidate's belief that costs can be controlled without spending limits. "Gov. Romney has proposed no cap on premium support in his own plan," Chen wrote, providing no additional detail.
Not having some kind of limit sends the wrong signal to the ealth care industry, said economist Joe Antos of the business-oriented American Enterprise Institute.
"I think that some bitter medicine is going to have to be administered here," said Antos. "For this policy to work, at least initially, you have to make it clear to the health care sector that there are
financial limits to what Medicare is going to pay for."
Former U.S. Comptroller General David Walker, a leading deficit-reduction advocate, said it's hard to understand how the Romney plan would work because so much of it remains fuzzy.
"I just don't know that we have enough details to meaningfully evaluate it at this point," Walker said. "People are trying to evaluate what the cost would be, but they just don't have enough facts to effectively evaluate it."
Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Contrary to popular belief, poinsettias are not toxic to humans or pets. Some mild side effects are possible if they are eaten.
A Fort Wayne man had the opportunity to have lunch with Nelson Mandela 20 years ago. He says the experience is something he has carried with him throughout the years.
The suspects face bank robbing charges, as well as charges of assaulting and putting in jeopardy the lives of others.
The yellow brick building that served for decades as the club house for the Elks Lodge 155 golf course in Fort Wayne is being demolished.
Buffalo Wild Wings donated $6,500 to the Boys & Girls Club's Fairfield location on Friday afternoon. The money will be used for youth sports tournaments.
A new event promises 12 days of delicious deals at Fort Wayne restaurants in January.
A woman arrested for shoplifting at a Fort Wayne Walmart identified herself as her husband's ex-wife when she was actually the man's current wife. The ex-wife then ended up getting arrested when the real wife failed to show up for court.
Gov. Mike Pence has ordered flags at Indiana state facilities to be flown at half-staff in tribute of Nelson Mandela and is asking businesses and residents to do so also to honor the world leader.
A big chunk of the U.S. is getting a blast of wintry weather. Some areas are experiencing frigid temperatures. Some are seeing snow and ice. Several deaths have been reported, most resulting from treacherous driving conditions. Hundreds of…
Frigid temperatures and a cold Saint Joseph River didn't stop approximately 100 students from jumping into the river as part of Homecoming Week at IPFW.
The Salvation Army and Toys for Tots are seeing a decline in donations this year because of a late Thanksgiving.
Global civil rights icon Nelson Mandela, whose legacy is ending South African apartheid, has died.
Fort Wayne is not expected to take the brunt of an approaching winter weather system, but everyone will experience frigid temperatures and some could see sleet and snow.
Thieves hit an Indianapolis home this week, stealing a large nativity scene from the front yard.
The Veteran Beer Company, a company employing solely veterans, is bringing its craft beers to Fort Wayne.