NEW YORK (AP) — A divided federal appeals court in Manhattan struck down the Defense of Marriage Act Thursday as unconstitutional, joining an appeals court in Boston in rejecting the law that defines marriage as between a man and a woman. The Supreme Court is expected to take up the case in the next year.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued its 2-to-1 ruling only weeks after hearing arguments on a lower court judge's findings that the 1996 law was unconstitutional.
The majority opinion written by Judge Dennis Jacobs rejected a section of the law that says "marriage" only means a legal union between one man and one woman as husband and wife and that the word "spouse" refers only to a person of the opposite sex who is a husband or a wife. A federal appeals court in Boston earlier this year also found it unconstitutional.
The issue is expected to be decided by the Supreme Court. The decision came less than a month after the court heard arguments on Sept. 27.
Lawyer Paul Clement, who had argued in support of the law on behalf of the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group of the House of Representatives, was traveling and did not immediately return a message for comment.
James Esseks, an attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union, called the ruling "a watershed moment in the legal movement for lesbian and gay rights."
"It's fabulous news for same-sex couples in New York and other states," he said.
Esseks said the 2nd Circuit went farther than the appeals court in Boston by saying that when the government discriminates against gay people, the courts will presume that the discrimination is unconstitutional.
In striking down the law, the Jacobs wrote that the law's "classification of same-sex spouses was not substantially related to an important government interest" and thus violated the equal protection clause of the Constitution.
He said the law was written so broadly that it touches more than a thousand federal laws. He said "homosexuals are not in a position to adequately protect themselves from the discriminatory wishes of the majoritarian public."
He rejected arguments that the definition of marriage was traditional.
"Even if preserving tradition were in itself an important goal, DOMA is not a means to achieve it," he said.
Judge Chester Straub dissented, saying that if the government was to change its understanding of marriage, "I believe it is for the American people to do so."
"Courts should not intervene where there is a robust political debate because doing so poisons the political well, imposing a destructive anti-majoritarian constitutional ruling on a vigorous debate," he said.
The ruling came in a case brought by Edith Windsor. She sued the government in November 2010 because she was told to pay $363,053 in federal estate tax after her partner of 44 years, Thea Spyer, died in 2009. They had married in Canada in 2007.
The law, which denies federal recognition of same-sex marriages and affirms the right of states to refuse to recognize such marriages, was passed by Congress and signed by President Bill Clinton after it appeared in 1993 that Hawaii might legalize gay marriage. Since then, many states have banned gay marriage but several have approved it, including Massachusetts and New York.
Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Four workers at a University of Notre Dame campus bar will soon be sharing a $10,000 tip.
The Indiana Department of Transportation plans to open the intersection of Union Chapel Road and Auburn Road at noon on Wednesday.
A local couple received a special honor Tuesday night. Rose and Denny Beuchel are the recipients of the 2013 Neighbor of the Year award.
IPFW hosted a cupcake eating contest Tuesday as part of the university's week-long Homecoming celebration.
Eastside High School was locked down Tuesday after police discovered a man on school property with two loaded guns
A Kosciusko County teen charged with murder and ordered to spend 25 years behind bars is getting a new shot at freedom. All because of a new law passed by Indiana lawmakers earlier this year.
A husband and wife were hurt in a violent home invasion and robbery last Friday night in New Haven.
The group hired to study Fort Wayne's rivers officially kicked off its research downtown Tuesday morning. The study by Houston-based SWA Group will take 12 to 18 months to complete.
With Christmas only three weeks away, lots of people are busy decorating and putting up their trees.
But do you go for the real tree, or plastic? Did you know real trees are a big benefit to both the environment and local economy?
Mayor Tom Henry spoke out Tuesday along with a bipartisan group of Indiana mayors who are opposed to HJR-6, the proposed constitutional amendment that would ban same sex marriage in the state.
The coroner has identified the man who was found shot to death an alley Sunday afternoon. His death marks the 43rd homicide in Fort Wayne and Allen County in 2013.
Overall sales were up 9 percent for U.S. automakers with GM seeing a 14 percent increase led by strong gains in the sales of the Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra pickups, both of which are made at an assembly plant in Fort Wayne.
The University of Notre Dame is suing the Obama administration over a federal mandate that its health insurance plans for students and employees cover birth control.
Culver's will donate 10 percent of its sales on Wednesday, December 17 to help the Indiana communities affected by the November storms and tornadoes.
Police in Kosciusko County are trying to find the driver of a vehicle that hit a bicyclist from behind north of Warsaw at around 9:15 Monday evening, leaving the victim in serious condition.