FORT WAYNE, Ind. (AP) -- In September 2009, a Virginia man thought he bought a 1930 Duesenberg automobile that once belonged to William Randolph Hearst.
And while James Scott paid nearly $3 million in what a judge called a rigged auction for the car, he never received the title to the vehicle. After trying for a few months to secure the title, Scott sued a number of people and businesses in connection with the sale of the car, including a Missouri car dealer, Mark Hyman; a Dowagiac, Mich., couple, Donald and Joan Lyons; Kruse International and the Auburn Cord Duesenberg Automobile Museum.
Scott also sued now-convicted Indianapolis businessman Timothy Durham, a former board member of the museum currently serving a 50-year federal prison sentence for wire fraud.
Durham and his partners, James F. Cochran and Rick D. Snow, were accused of running a Ponzi scheme to defraud about 5,000 investors in Fair Finance Co. of more than $200 million to fund other businesses and support a lavish lifestyle.
Now, two years later, all that remains of Scott's civil lawsuit is Durham as the defendant, with Kruse International having been dismissed. The Lyonses have settled with Scott and the museum and are now taking up Scott's claims against Durham, The Journal Gazette reported.
In September, U.S. District Chief Judge Philip P. Simon ruled in favor of Scott and the Lyonses and against Durham - finding Durham violated the terms of the auction contract.
Simon also ruled a jury will decide whether Durham committed fraud in the auction of the classic car.
According to court documents, the Hearst Duesenberg was to be auctioned at a special event at the museum, placed up for sale by Durham, who claimed ownership of the car and had it on display at the museum. The Lyonses saw the car and offered a million dollars for it before the auction, court records said.
But Durham wanted to keep the car in the auction, with the knowledge of the museum. The Lyonses were to pose as unsuspecting winning bidders. However, Scott appeared on the scene, bidding nearly $3 million for the car by telephone. As the bids climbed, Durham and the Lyonses agreed to split the profits of the auction, court records said.
"So the auction was planned to be a sham, and everyone seemed to know it," Judge Simon wrote in his opinion. "As the bidding neared $3 million, the whole scheme unraveled."
Scott won the auction and the museum shipped the car, but when it came time for Durham to deliver the title, he was unable to do so, having put the vehicle up as collateral for a loan to one of his companies, court records said.
Durham claimed he was not aware that a lending institution held the title to the vehicle. And whenever he was asked in depositions about the title and what he'd done to try to obtain it, Durham asserted his Fifth Amendment rights against self-incrimination, according to court documents.
The judge ruled Durham's actions brought about financial harm. The Lyonses, Hyman and the museum have returned $2.13 million to Scott, but $1 million in proceeds is still in Durham's possession, according to court documents.
The case is on hold for the time being -- awaiting a status hearing while Durham starts his prison sentence. Durham is no longer on the board at the ACD Museum, but the museum had to pay $30,000 to the trustee of an Ohio company embroiled in one of Durham's schemes.
This month, Durham claimed he was broke. A federal judge in his criminal case ordered Durham to pay $202.8 million in restitution, though he received credit for $6 million that already has been recovered.
No trial date has yet been set in the case of the Hearst Duesenberg. Durham was placed temporarily in a federal prison in Kentucky, to be transferred to a more permanent placement sometime between November and January, according to court documents.
Information from: The Journal Gazette, http://www.journalgazette.net
Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Contrary to popular belief, poinsettias are not toxic to humans or pets. Some mild side effects are possible if they are eaten.
A Fort Wayne man had the opportunity to have lunch with Nelson Mandela 20 years ago. He says the experience is something he has carried with him throughout the years.
The suspects face bank robbing charges, as well as charges of assaulting and putting in jeopardy the lives of others.
The yellow brick building that served for decades as the club house for the Elks Lodge 155 golf course in Fort Wayne is being demolished.
Buffalo Wild Wings donated $6,500 to the Boys & Girls Club's Fairfield location on Friday afternoon. The money will be used for youth sports tournaments.
A new event promises 12 days of delicious deals at Fort Wayne restaurants in January.
A woman arrested for shoplifting at a Fort Wayne Walmart identified herself as her husband's ex-wife when she was actually the man's current wife. The ex-wife then ended up getting arrested when the real wife failed to show up for court.
Gov. Mike Pence has ordered flags at Indiana state facilities to be flown at half-staff in tribute of Nelson Mandela and is asking businesses and residents to do so also to honor the world leader.
A big chunk of the U.S. is getting a blast of wintry weather. Some areas are experiencing frigid temperatures. Some are seeing snow and ice. Several deaths have been reported, most resulting from treacherous driving conditions. Hundreds of…
Frigid temperatures and a cold Saint Joseph River didn't stop approximately 100 students from jumping into the river as part of Homecoming Week at IPFW.
The Salvation Army and Toys for Tots are seeing a decline in donations this year because of a late Thanksgiving.
Global civil rights icon Nelson Mandela, whose legacy is ending South African apartheid, has died.
Fort Wayne is not expected to take the brunt of an approaching winter weather system, but everyone will experience frigid temperatures and some could see sleet and snow.
Thieves hit an Indianapolis home this week, stealing a large nativity scene from the front yard.
The Veteran Beer Company, a company employing solely veterans, is bringing its craft beers to Fort Wayne.