FORT WAYNE, Ind. (WISH) - An Allen County judge granted the prosecution’s request to dismiss a motion to suppress blood evidence in vial 1 in the David Bisard case on Wednesday, which means it will be allowed at trial.
"I've not seen any allegation that there's a flaw with vial 1, other than - we don't think it's right and we'll prove it. That's for trial,” the judge said Wednesday.
Before the judge granted the request on Monday, IU McKinney School of Law Professor Frances Watson called the motion critical to the future of the case.
“This is the big time key to the state's proof,” she said. “Without that [evidence], it makes the drunk driving charge much harder to prove. And, the criminal recklessness charge is tied to that. If there are chain of custody problems, then that evidence wouldn't be admissible.”
Bisard is accused of driving drunk in August 2010 , crashing his patrol car into a group of motorcyclists and killing Eric Wells. Prosecutors say the blood draw taken after the crash shows he was drunk at more than twice the legal limit at the time.
The latest request to throw out that blood evidence was debated during a two-day hearing in late July. The dates had been set aside to consider evidence on at least 10 separate evidentiary motions, but Bisard's attorney John Kautzman said he received last-minute evidence just days before the hearing, including nine interviews from prosecutors conducting an internal investigation at IMPD.
Prosecutors contend that the question of admissibility has already been answered.
Though the original Marion County judge hearing the case, Grant Hawkins, said the blood was improperly drawn, an Indiana Court of Appeals ruling overturned it. The Indiana Supreme Court declined to hear the case, effectively upholding the appeals court ruling.
But, Katuzman’s latest filing argued that the blood wasn't handled properly after it was drawn. He was challenging the "chain of custody.”
”The idea of chain of custody is to authenticate the evidence, to be sure that it is what it purports to be, and to identify it,” Watson said. “The state has to show that the blood they drew from his arm is the blood that was tested. What the state has to show is what we call links in the chain of custody--the people that touched it, where it was, and who had it. They have to connect the dots, if you will, or connect the links. Sometimes, if there is a link missing, it will defeat the chain of custody. But, if the link is only weak, then the evidence is admitted.”
During the last hearing, Katuzman told Judge John Surbeck that the officer transporting the blood stopped at a restaurant for an hour, and that a second vial of blood sat unrefrigerated for months.
Watson didn't think the judge would buy Katuzman's arguments against the validity of the samples on Wednesday.
"In my opinion, the lawyers are fighting a good fight. But, they're smart enough to know they won't be successful. That blood test, given that court of appeals opinion, that blood test is coming in,” she said.
Asked what role overturning an existing appeals court ruling might play, Watson smiled.
“I would say most judges would know better,” she said. “But, each case is different.”
Watson also thinks prosecutors will win their argument to throw out comments made by former prosecutor Carl Brizzi on the admissibility of the blood evidence.
“What Carl Brizzi said is hearsay. He's got no firsthand knowledge of those events. He himself didn't participate in the chain of custody, or the testing or the blood draw. So, he has no firsthand knowledge,” she said.
The judge will also consider a motion Wednesday from prosecutors asking that David Bisard's second DUI arrest in Lawrence earlier this year be admissible as evidence in the trial for his 2010 crash.
Watson thinks that will be a much tougher sell.
“The general rule is: you can't prove he was driving drunk by evidence of subsequent drunk driving. Why? Because it's more prejudicial than probative. It doesn't go to the elements of whether or not on this day he was [driving drunk]. At this point, Bisard's got a strong argument that [he’s] innocent of that. He’s not been convicted of that. And, within the rules of our law, that means you can't reference that, because [he’s] an innocent man. I would expect that the state would not be able to use those subsequent bad acts, unless somehow the door was opened by the defendant,” she said.
The court is expected to begin hearing evidence Wednesday morning.
Police said a man barricaded himself inside of a home on Genessee Avenue early Sunday morning for more than two hours after threatening to commit suicide.
Detectives believe a three-year-old boy may have shot himself at a home in Indianapolis Saturday night. Police said the shooting appears to have been accidental.
There will be several holiday-themed events this weekend in the Fort Wayne area, including Christmas displays, children’s parties, visits from Santa Claus, and more.
A man is in critical condition after a stabbing early Sunday morning in Bluebird Court, off of St. Joe Road.
The 122nd Fighter Wing hosted the annual Airman of the Year Awards on Saturday afternoon to celebrate the achievements of members of the 122nd.
Saturday marked the 72nd anniversary of the Pearl Harbor attack. Fort Wayne area veterans and their families met for a service at the Allen County War Memorial Coliseum to remember those who lost their lives back on December 7, 1941.
A doctor who performs abortions in Fort Wayne, Gary and South Bend has been asked to appear before the Indiana Medical Licensing Board.
Each year, students at Taylor University attend a men's basketball game and are completely silent until the Trojans score their 10th point of the game. The game is known as "Silent Night."
Governor Mike Pence is directing flags at Indiana state facilities be flown at half-staff on Saturday, Dec. 7 in honor of Pearl Harbor Remembrance Day.
A national campaign wants the NFL's Washington Redskins to change its name to not be offensive to Native Americans, and it could effect teams across the country.
The Lilly Endowment Inc. has given more than $62 million to 39 Indiana colleges and universities to increase employment opportunities for college graduates. receive
A two-car crash tied up traffic for a short time on Illinois Road at the entrance to Jefferson Pointe.
It's been a year since FBI agents and police raided several homes in Fort Wayne. The center of the investigation was Michael Fabini's home.
Contrary to popular belief, poinsettias are not toxic to humans or pets. Some mild side effects are possible if they are eaten.
A Fort Wayne man had the opportunity to have lunch with Nelson Mandela 20 years ago. He says the experience is something he has carried with him throughout the years.